Can I Sue My Spouse’s Lover For Alienation Of Affection And/Or Criminal Conversation?

Daphne Edwards Divorce & Family Law, PC • January 2, 2020

Share this article

Julie was cooking dinner and her husband Tom was in the shower. Tom, who usually carries his cell phone with him everywhere he goes, had left his cell phone on the kitchen counter. Tom’s cell phone dinged and Julie glanced at the phone to see a text message pop up from Tom’s coworker, Kelly. The message read: “I miss you. I can’t wait until we can be together all the time. XO.” Julie began reading the stream of text messages to and from Kelly and suddenly found herself immersed in the salacious details of her husband’s affair. Julie felt emotionally numb and knew that, from that point on, her world would never be the same.

North Carolina is one of a handful of states in the United States that still recognizes the legal claims of “alienation of affection” and “criminal conversation.” Most states have abolished such claims. Alienation of affection allows a spouse to sue a third party for alienating the affection of the other spouse. Most often the third party is a lover. However, anyone who wrongfully and maliciously interferes in a marriage and alienates the affection of a spouse could potentially be sued for alienation of affection, including a parent, friend, or a stepchild.

When a lawsuit for alienation of affection is filed against a spouse’s lover, it will most likely include an additional claim for “criminal conversation.” A claim for criminal conversation arises when a third party engages in sexual intercourse with another person’s spouse. Thus, if your spouse has an affair or begins a new romantic relationship before you are separated , you may have legal grounds to sue the third party for alienation of affection and/or criminal conversation.

Alienation of affection and criminal conversation are civil tort claims that can entitle an aggrieved spouse to recover monetary damages from the third party. The aggrieved spouse’s lawsuit must allege specific damages, such as emotional distress, loss of income, and/or loss of consortium (conjugal relations). Most cases for alienation of affection and/or criminal conversation, if not settled at mediation, are tried before a jury.

Even though you may have a legal basis to sue a third party for alienation of affection and/or criminal conversation, there are pros and cons to filing a lawsuit to pursue these claims. Some factors that your attorney may take into consideration in advising you whether or not to pursue such claims may include the following:

Marriages are complicated, and the facts and circumstances of each case are unique. Your attorney is in the best position to view your situation objectively and give you advice on whether or not you should proceed with a lawsuit for alienation of affection and/or criminal conversation.

Daphne Edwards represents clients who are pursuing claims for alienation of affection and criminal conversation. Ms. Edwards also represents clients who are in need of an attorney to defend such claims. If you are considering pursuing a claim for alienation of affection for criminal conversation, you should be aware that a three-year statute of limitations applies to both alienation of affection and criminal conversation, and time may be of the essence in filing your lawsuit to preserve your claims. Likewise, if a lawsuit has been filed against you, there are some valid defenses that can be raised and, it is crucial to your defense that you file a timely response.

For more information please  visit our site  or  contact  attorney  Daphne Edwards

  • Are you mentally and emotionally equipped to have the personal details of your life made public? Lawsuits are public records. By suing someone for alienation of affection and/or criminal conversation, you are opening the door for that person to delve into the intimate details of your life. Your marriage will essentially be put on trial and subjected to scrutiny.
  • Can a jury (or judge) be convinced that love and affection existed between you and your spouse before the third party interfered? If you and your spouse were in an unhappy marriage and contemplating separation prior to your spouse becoming involved with a third party, you may have difficulty establishing that integral part of the claim for alienation of affection.
  • Is there sufficient evidence of adultery (or inclination and opportunity to have committed adultery) between your spouse and the third party? Even if your spouse and the third party have been very careful, there is usually some evidence to support such conduct if it has occurred. Cell phone records, text messages, emails, social media, and financial records, such as credit card statements can be helpful in establishing the location and togetherness of your spouse and the third party.
  • What do you hope to accomplish by pursuing a lawsuit for alienation of affection and/or criminal conversation? Prevailing on claims for alienation of affection and/or criminal conversation may entitle you to monetary awards. If a jury finds in your favor and awards you substantial monies in damages from the third party, the verdict may be worthless if the third party has no income or assets from which to pay. A monetary judgment against a third party who is “judgment proof” is much like a Pyrrhic victory – you will have spent a lot of time and money and the damage to your marriage will still be done.
  • Some people who file a lawsuit for alienation of affection and/or criminal conversation may do so in the hopes of putting pressure on their spouse to give them a more favorable settlement in their divorce-related matters. However, your divorce proceedings are separate from any proceedings involving a lawsuit for alienation of affection and/or criminal conversation. If your spouse is no longer involved with the third party, filing a lawsuit against the third party is not going to enhance your bargaining position for a better divorce settlement.

Recent Posts

A bright, sunny view of a city skyline with modern buildings, train tracks in the foreground, and a clear blue sky.
By Daphne Edwards February 20, 2026
Quick Summary: Under North Carolina law, legal custody refers to a parent’s authority to make important decisions for a child—like education, medical care, and religion—while physical custody refers to where the child lives and the day-to-day care schedule. The distinction matters because a parent can share legal custody but have different physical custody arrangements. At Daphne Edwards Divorce & Family Law, PC , serving Raleigh, Cary, and Wake County , understanding how courts treat each type helps families plan custody arrangements that work for their children. What Is Legal Custody? Legal custody is about decision-making authority . A parent with legal custody has the right to help decide major aspects of a child’s life, including: School and educational needs Health care and medical treatment Religious upbringing Extracurricular activities In North Carolina, courts typically favor both parents sharing legal custody unless there are circumstances—like a history of abuse—that would make shared legal decision-making harmful to the child. Shared legal custody means both parents must cooperate and consult on key decisions. When only one parent has legal custody, that parent makes the major choices without requiring agreement from the other. Legal custody often comes up in broader discussions about parenting rights; you can read more about custody as a whole on our Child Custody page → https://www.daphneedwardslaw.com/child-custody . What Is Physical Custody? Physical custody refers to where and with whom a child lives day to day . The two broad types are: Primary physical custody: The child lives mostly with one parent, and the other has scheduled parenting time. Joint physical custody: The child splits significant time between both parents’ homes. While legal custody focuses on decisions, physical custody focuses on time and routine —sleepovers, school nights, holidays, and visitation schedules. North Carolina family courts in Wake County, Raleigh, and Cary aim to craft physical custody arrangements that reflect the child’s best interests, stability, and routines while supporting meaningful relationships with both parents when possible. How Courts Award Legal and Physical Custody In awarding both legal and physical custody, North Carolina judges follow the best interests of the child standard . This means they consider multiple factors, including: Each parent’s ability to provide for the child’s needs The child’s age and developmental stage The quality of the parent-child relationship The child’s adjustment to home, school, and community Any history of abuse or neglect For legal custody , courts look closely at how well parents can communicate and collaborate. Shared legal custody works when both parents demonstrate willingness to cooperate. If one parent consistently undermines the other or cannot communicate effectively, a judge may award sole legal custody to the other parent. For physical custody , courts consider the child’s living arrangements, schedules, and stability . Joint physical custody doesn’t necessarily mean a 50/50 split—it means both parents have frequent and meaningful contact with the child. The actual schedule can vary widely based on work schedules, school, and what’s most practical for the family. Common Custody Arrangements North Carolina families may see several custody patterns, such as: Joint legal and joint physical custody: Parents share decision making and significant parenting time. Joint legal, primary physical with one parent: Parents share decisions, but the child lives mostly with one parent. Sole legal, primary physical custody: One parent has both decision making and primary physical care, often when there are safety concerns. Each family’s situation is different, and the ideal arrangement reflects what’s healthiest and most stable for the child. How Decision-Making Works in Practice In shared legal custody , parents must communicate and agree on major decisions. If they can’t agree, they may try: **Negotiation between parents Mediation Court intervention** For disputes that require legal modifications, North Carolina allows parents to seek changes when circumstances shift; you can learn more on our Modifications page → In sole legal custody , one parent has the authority to make decisions, but many parents still choose to keep the other parent informed when possible for the child’s benefit. Physical custody schedules typically spell out routines—week on/week off, alternating weekends, holiday rotations, summer breaks, and more. Clear agreements help reduce conflict and support predictability for children. Understanding Custody for Your Family Understanding the difference between legal and physical custody helps parents make informed choices and work toward arrangements that reflect their child’s best interests. Whether you’re navigating initial custody decisions or considering adjustments as children grow, having clear guidance matters. At Daphne Edwards Divorce & Family Law, PC , we help families in Raleigh, Cary, and Wake County understand custody options and advocate for arrangements that support stability and meaningful relationships. Ready to Talk About Custody? Custody decisions have a profound impact on your child’s life. Schedule a custody consultation with our experienced family law attorneys to discuss your unique situation and the best path forward. We’re here to help you protect your child’s future with clarity and confidence. 
A panoramic view of the Boston skyline with green trees, a baseball diamond, and tall buildings under a clear blue sky.
By Daphne Edwards February 3, 2026
In North Carolina, divorce is a no-fault process that requires spouses to live separate and apart for one full year before filing for absolute divorce. Court involvement is minimal for the divorce itself but may be required for issues like property division, child custody, and support if those matters aren’t resolved beforehand. For families in Raleigh and Wake County , understanding the steps ahead can reduce stress and help you plan strategically. How Divorce Works in North Carolina Divorce in North Carolina follows a structured legal process, but not every divorce looks the same. Some cases are relatively straightforward, while others involve complex financial or parenting issues that require court guidance. At Daphne Edwards Divorce & Family Law, PC , we help individuals and families in Raleigh, Cary, and Wake County understand each stage of divorce so they can make informed decisions and protect their future. The One-Year Separation Requirement Before filing for divorce in North Carolina, spouses must live separate and apart for at least 12 consecutive months . This means: Living in separate residences At least one spouse intends the separation to be permanent No resumption of the marital relationship during the year This separation period is mandatory, even if both spouses fully agree to divorce. Many couples use this time to negotiate important issues and put agreements in place before filing. Separation Agreements: Resolving Issues Early During the separation year, spouses can enter into a separation agreement , a legally binding contract that addresses issues such as: Division of property and debts Child custody and visitation Child support Spousal support (alimony) A well-drafted separation agreement often allows couples to avoid future court battles and proceed with divorce more smoothly. Filing for Absolute Divorce in Wake County Once the one-year separation requirement is met, either spouse may file for absolute divorce in Wake County family court. Absolute divorce officially ends the marriage. Key points to know: North Carolina does not require either spouse to prove fault The divorce filing focuses only on dissolving the marriage The court does not automatically decide property, custody, or support unless those issues are raised separately If all other issues are already resolved through a separation agreement, the divorce itself is often quick and uncontested. Equitable Distribution of Property North Carolina uses equitable distribution , which means marital property is divided fairly—but not necessarily equally. Marital property generally includes: Assets and debts acquired during the marriage Retirement accounts earned during the marriage Real estate purchased together Separate property (such as inheritances or assets owned before marriage) may not be divided, depending on the circumstances. If spouses cannot agree on property division, the court may step in to decide how assets and debts are distributed. Child Custody and Parenting Issues When children are involved, custody decisions focus on the best interests of the child . North Carolina courts consider factors such as: Each parent’s ability to provide stability The child’s relationship with each parent The parents’ ability to cooperate and communicate Custody arrangements may be resolved through agreement, mediation, or court proceedings if necessary. Child Support and Spousal Support Child support in North Carolina is generally calculated using statewide guidelines based on income, custody schedules, and certain expenses. Spousal support (alimony) depends on factors like: Length of the marriage Each spouse’s income and earning capacity Contributions made during the marriage Support issues can be addressed during separation or decided by the court if spouses cannot agree. When Is Court Involvement Required? Court involvement is usually required when: Spouses cannot agree on property division Custody or support disputes remain unresolved One party contests claims made by the other However, many divorces in Raleigh and Wake County resolve most issues outside of court through negotiation and legally binding agreements. Moving Forward with Confidence Divorce is a legal process, but it’s also a major life transition. Understanding North Carolina’s divorce requirements helps you make decisions that protect your finances, your parenting rights, and your peace of mind. At Daphne Edwards Divorce & Family Law, PC , we guide clients in Raleigh , Cary , and Wake County through every stage of divorce with clarity and compassion. Schedule a Confidential Consultation If you’re considering divorce or already separated, schedule a confidential consultation with our experienced family law team. We’re here to answer your questions, explain your options, and help you move forward with confidence.
By On Behalf ofDaphne Edwards Divorce & Family Law, PC September 9, 2025
Daphne Edwards Divorce & Family Law, PC Legal Blog
By On Behalf ofDaphne Edwards Divorce & Family Law, PC September 9, 2025
If your co-parent plans to move out, it can disrupt your routine, parenting time and long-term relationship with your child. Relocation can create one of the most challenging situations in child custody cases. Taking early, deliberate steps can help you protect your relationship and prepare for how the court may evaluate the situation.
By On Behalf ofDaphne Edwards Divorce & Family Law, PC March 24, 2025
When you think about divorce, you might picture heated courtroom battles and bitter arguments portrayed in movies or TV shows. Perhaps you’ve witnessed friends or family members go through contentious divorces that dragged on for months or even years.
By On Behalf ofDaphne Edwards Divorce & Family Law, PC October 17, 2024
One of the biggest concerns of spouses during a divorce is how to support themselves through the separation. In a marriage, couples often divide chores and responsibilities. For instance, you could decide to stay home and care for the house and the children while your spouse works. This arrangement may work well while married, but divorce could change this dynamic.
By Daphne Edwards Divorce & Family Law, PC February 12, 2024
We are pleased to announce that Daphne Edwards has been selected to Business North Carolina Magazine’s 2016 Legal Elite Family Law Section.
By Daphne Edwards Divorce & Family Law, PC February 12, 2024
Daphne Edwards has attained an AV Preeminent Peer Review Rating from Martindale Hubbell. Daphne Edwards is 1997 graduate of Golden Gate University School of Law. She holds an undergraduate degree in Political Science from University of Oregon, and attended North Carolina State University. She served as Clerk to North Carolina Supreme Court Justice Robert Orr and U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals Judge Proctor Hug, Jr., Ninth Circuit, and as Staff Attorney for the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. In North Carolina, she has served as Assistant Attorney General for the North Carolina Department of Justice and Assistant District Attorney for the District Attorney’s Office for Alamance County. She has taught law at both Campbell Law School and Golden Gate University School of Law, where she received the 1997 Faculty Award for Academic Excellence. Daphne is a member of the Family Law and Appellate Practice Sections of the North Carolina Bar Association, the Family Law Section of the American Bar Association, the Wake County Bar Association, and North Carolina Association of Women Attorneys. In 2016, she was honored to be included in Business North Carolina Magazine’s Legal Elite Family Law Section. She focuses her practice exclusively on matters relating to divorce and family law and adds to the firm’s successful appellate history.
By Daphne Edwards Divorce & Family Law, PC February 11, 2024
One of the critical steps in the equitable distribution process is to place a value on all property classified as marital property. In North Carolina, all marital property (which includes assets and debts) must be valued as of the date of separation.
By Daphne Edwards Divorce & Family Law, PC February 11, 2024
The upheaval and turmoil that accompany divorce can be devastating and far-reaching. Divorce has the potential to impact every major aspect of a person’s life: physical, emotional, mental, spiritual, social, and financial. Divorce is stressful, but for some people, it is also emotionally traumatic. While it is common for people going through divorce to experience a wide range of emotions, including denial, grief, hurt, and anger, some people feel paralyzed and may find it difficult to cope with the ordinary demands of everyday life, including parental responsibilities and employment obligations.
Show More